THE DANGER OF POPULISM MACROECONOMIC POPULISM IN LATIN AMERICA. IS COLOMBIA THE EXCEPTION?

Rosalvina Otálora Cortés

Rosalvina Otálora Cortés Universidad Nacional Universidad Libre

Resumen

In recent decades, populism has regained prominence in Latin America. It is expressed in forms of government from left or right as it happens in Venezuela with Hugo Chavez and Alvaro Uribe in Colombia, as well as in mobilization of some sectors of the population. This ambiguous concept takes on different meanings. From the economic point of view, macroeconomic populism emphasizes growth through redistributive policies in the short term to increase consumption, neglecting macroeconomic balance, especially with regard to inflation and fiscal deficit.
This paper argues that macroeconomic populism is not new and has been applied in Latin America repeatedly. With some differences and at different times of economic history, the governments of Argentina, Chile, Peru and Venezuela, have resorted to the use of fiscal, monetary and credit expansive policies and overvaluation of the currency to accelerate growth and redistribute income. When applied there are concerns about fiscal and exchange
restrictions.

Biografía del autor/a

Rosalvina Otálora Cortés, Universidad Nacional Universidad Libre

The author is Magíster in Political Studies of the Universidad Nacional of Colombia. She is Economist and Lawyer. She is currently the Director of Economy and Conflict and Researcher of Libre University. The author is grateful for the contributions realized by Claudia Yineth Hernández Bocanegra, student of Santo Tomás University.

Citas

AMERICAN BUREAU. (1985). The Poverty Brokers: The IMF and Latinoamerica. Ancora Editores, Bogotá.

ARDITI, B. (2009). Populism as an Internal Periphery of Democratic Politics. In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a Mirror of Democracy (pp. 51-70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Económica de Argentina, SA.

BANK OF THE REPUBLIC. (1998). Introduction to Economic Analysis: the Colombian Case, Second Edition, Bogotá.

BARROS, S. (2009). Discursive Continuities Menem Rupture. In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a Mirror of Democracy (pp. 51- 70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Económica de Argentina, SA.

BOWMAN, G. (2009). Constitutive and Imaginar Nationalist Violence: The Construction of the “People” in Palestine and the Former Yugoslavia. In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a Mirror of Democracy (pp. 51- 70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Económica de Argentina, SAS.A.

CEPAL. (2009). Reaction of Latin America governments to international crisis: a little presentation of political measures announced from 30 june of 2009. Santiago: División de Desarrollo Económico, Comisión Económica para América Latina. 2009.

CIES. (2010). Dare to Fiscal Policy in Perú. Consorcio de Investigación Económica y Social. Lima, December of 2006. Disponible en: http://cies.org.pe/files/DyP/dyp27.pdf

CLAVIJO, Sergio. (2000).Central Banking and Macroeconomic Coordination: The Case of Colombia, october.

CORRALES, Javier. (2006). “Hugo Boss”. Foreign Policy, January-February.

CUBA, Elmer. Evolution of economie and political macroeconomie. An Analysis of Alejandro Toledo government (2001-2003). Available on: http://www.gestiopolis.com/ canales5/eco/consorcio/eys52/archivos/52-

evolucion-economica-gobierno-toledo-en-elperu. pdf.

DEGREGORI, Carlos Iván. (2001). The Decade of Anti-politics: the Rise and Flight of Alberto Fujimori and Vladimiro Montesinos / Carlos Ivan Degregori, Lima: Instituto de Estudios Peruanos.

DOORNBUSH, Rudiger. (1997). The Macroeconomics of Populism. Fondo de Cultura Económica, Mexico City.

EDWARDS, S. (2009). The Washington Consensus and the recurrence of the crisis, 1989-2002. In S. Edwards (Ed.), Populism and Markets: The Dilemma of Latin America (pp.33-94). Bogotá: Grupo Editorial Norma

EDWARDS, S. (2009). Future Challenges. In S. Edwards (Ed.), Populism and Markets: The Dilemma of Latin America (pp.33-94). Bogotá: Grupo Editorial Norma.

EDWARDS, S. (2009). A long Decline: from Independence to the Washington Consensus. In S. Edwards (Ed.), Populism and Markets:

The Dilemma of Latin America (pp. 33-94). Bogotá: Grupo Editorial Norma.

FONTAINE T, ANDREW JOHN. Independent Central Bank: The Pursuit of Stability, Chapter 10, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile. Research Associate, Center for Public Studies.

GARRETON, Manuel Antonio. (2010. Michelle Bachelet´s governent and ChileanPolitic. ¿End of political cycle?. Available on: http://www.manuelantoniogarreton.cl/documentos/2010/gobierno_bachelet_es.pdf

GERVASONI, Carlos. (2010). Political crisis política and financial crisis in the Aliances´ government in Argentina (1999-2001). Available On: en: http://repositories.lib. utexas.edu/bitstream/handle/2152/4090/ gervasoni.pdf?sequence=2

GOMEZ ARRUBLA, Fabio. History of the Bank of the Republic. Bank of the Republic, Bogotá, 1983.

GUTIERREZ, Ricardo Raúl. Argentine crisis at the end of milenio. A teaching for Political Economie. Department of economie. UNS. Ausgut, 2003. Available on: http://www. aaep.org.ar/espa/anales/ PDF_03/Gutierrez.pdf

HAUSSMAN, Ricardo (1995). “Impact of Public Finances on Distribution”, In: “Adjustment Policies and Poverty: False Dilemmas, Real Problems, ed. José Nuñez del Arco, Washington, DC. Interamerican Development Bank.

JIMENES, Felipe. (2007). Available on: http:/ /felixjimenez.blogspot.com/2007/05/porqu- el-per-sigue-creciendo.html. Consulted on 21/08/10.

KALMANOVITZ, Salomón. (2000). Central bank independence and democracy in Latin America. Paper prepared for the Colloque “Mondialisation économique des sociétés et gouvernement: l’Amérique latine, a laboraotire?.” Organisé par le GREITD, l’IRD et les Universités de Paris (CRI-IEDES), Paris, june 2000.

KRUGMAN, Paul. (1997). Economía Política internacional. Mac Graw Hill.

KRUGMAN, Paul. R. (1999). Returning to the big economic depression. Editorial Norma, Colección Vitral, 1999.

LACLAU, E. (2009). Populism: Can you Tell us the Name? In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a Mirror of Democracy (pp. 51- 70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Economica de Argentina, SA.

LARRAÍN B. • RODRIGO VERGARA M The Economic Transformation of Chile, p. 349 et seq.

LOPEZ, Margarita. (2003). “The Venezuelan Caracazo of 1989: Popular Protest and Institutional Weakness.” Journal of Latinoamericando studies, 35: 117-137.

LOWNES, J. (2009). Foundational violence of political hegemony, conservative populism of George Wallace. In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a mirror of democracy (pp. 51-70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Económica de Argentina, SA.

MACHINEA, Jose Luis. (2004). Latin America: Return to growth in this decade?, CEPAL.

MANKIW, N. Gregory (2003).Principles of Economy. Second edition. Mac Graw Hill. Translation by Esther Rabasco Espartiz and Luis Toharía Cortés, Madrid.

MARCHESI, Giancarlo. The Evolution of Economic and Social Policy in Latin America: A Comparative View. The University of Texas at Austin, Institute of Latin American Studies, Center for Latin American Social

Policy (CLASPO). Researcher Visiting. Perú,

February, 2004, p. 12.

MORA and ARAUJO, Manuel (1995). From Perón to Menem. A History of Peronismo. On: Atilio Borón et al. Peronismo and Menemismo. Populism in Argentina. Buenos Aires, El cielo por asalto, p. 47-66.

MOUFFE, C. (2009). The End of Politics and the Challenge to Right-Wing Populism. In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a Mirror of Democracy (pp. 51-70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Económica de Argentina, SA

PANIZZA, Francisco. (Editor). Populism as a mirror of democracy (pp. 51-70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Economica de Argentina, SA.

PARAMIO, Ludolf. Left turn and the return of populism. Revista Nueva Sociedad N. 205. P. 62 et seq. Presidency of the Republic. Website www.presidencia.gov.co, 2010.

PINTO OCAMPO, Maria Teresa. (2004). Between Repression and Conciliation: the Growers in Chapare and Putumayo. Final Report of the Contest: Social Movements and New Conflicts in Latin America and the

Caribbean. Regional Scholarship Program CLACSO. 2004. Available at: http:// bibliotecavirtual.clacso.org.ar/ar/libros/becas/ 2002/mov/pinto.pdf

REYES, O. (2009). Skinhead Conservatism: a Populist Project Failed. In F. Panizza, (Comp.). Populism as a Mirror of Democracy (pp. 51-70). Buenos Aires, Argentina: Fondo de Cultura Económica de Argentina, SA.

RODRIGUEZ, F. R (2008) “An Empty Revolution: The Unfulfilled Promises of Hugo Chavez.” Foreign Affairs, 87 (2). SANTISO, J. (1999). From the good Revolutionary “good liberal? About a strange Latin American chameleon. Paper presented at the Congress Science Po / The College of Mexico. Of the old populism of modern populism. Translation: Carmen Chalamanch. Mexico. URRUTIA, Miguel. (1997). Independent Central Bank and Democracy. Published in: Journal of Economics National University of Colombia Faculty of Economics Volume XVI Semester 1997.

VELASQUEZ VARGAS, A. and PINZÓN GARCIA, V. (2005). Public Safety and Public Expenditure: Reflections on the Colombian Case. Latin America Today Magazine, Vol 50, 2008, pp. 37-51. University of Salamanca,Spain. Available http://redalyc.uaemex.mx/

src/inicio/ArtPdfRed.jsp?iCve=30810929003

VILAS, M. Carlos. “Neoliberalism Populisms Recycled or Dry?. The Myth of Populism in Latin America. Political Sociology Journal, Curitiba, p. 135-151, June. 2004.

WALKER, Ignacio (2009). “Democracy and Populism in Latin America.” Kellogg Institute for International Studies, Working Paper 347